Build Your Own Sandwich
Build Your Own Sandwich for $7.49 - Make it a 1/2 Pound for $10.99
STEP 1: CHOOSE YOUR BREAD
Seadless Rye . Challah . Wheat . Onion Roll . Pretzel Roll
STEP 2: CHOOSE YOUR MEAT
Pick Up to Two or Add $1.75 for Each Additional Meat
Corned Beef (Lean add .85) . Pastrami (Lean add .85) . Turkey Pastrami . Roast Beef . Brisket . Grilled Chicken . Turkey . Chopped Liver . Salami . Chicken Salad . Tuna Salad . Egg Salad . Whitefish Salad . Salmon Salad
STEP 3: CHOOSE YOUR TOPPER
For Free: Tomato . Onion . Cucumber . Pickle . Sport Peppers . Pepperoni . Mayo . Spicy Mustard . Yellow Mustard . Ranch Dressing . BBQ Sauce . 1,000 Island Dressing . Italian Dressing Crunch
For $1: Hardboiled Egg . Fried Egg . Roasted Red Peppers . Cole Slaw . Fried Jalapeno . Fried Eggplant . Onion Rings
For .50: (Slice of Cheese, Smear of Cream Cheese) Cheddar . Swiss . Muenster . Provolone . Chive Cream Cheese . Plain Cream Cheese . Sauerkraut
For $2: Potato Pancake . Mozzarella Sticks
For $2.50: Chopped Liver . Chicken Fingers
STEP 4: CHOOSE YOUR SIDE
Homemade Potato Chips . Homemade Bagel Chips . Cole Slaw . Macaroni Salad . Potato Salad . Fruit Cup (Substitute Potato Knish, Potato Pancake or Kishka for Additional $1.25)
Wraps
Chicken Caesarromaine lettuce, asiago cheese, croutons, grilled chicken and caesar dressing |
$8.49 |
BBQ Chickenmixed greens, tomato, cucumber, onion, cheddar, tortilla strips and ranch |
$8.49 |
Buffalo Chickenmixed greens, tomato, olives, feta, peperoncini, Greek dressing |
$8.49 |
Mediteranean Wrapmixed greens, carrots, chives, crispy noodles and Asian sesame sauce |
$8.49 |
Asian ChickenLettuce, Carrots, Chives, Crispy Wontons & Asian Seasame Sauce |
$8.49 |
Veggie Specialmixed greens, tomato, cucumber, roasted red peppers, olives, cheddar, asiago and caesar dressing |
$7.49 |
Monsters of the Midway - GIANT SANDWICHES!
Woody Allena triple decker of corned beef and pastrami on rye |
$16.99 |
The R&Rcorned beef and brisket piled high with turkey and coleslaw under melted swiss all on a pretzel roll with a slice of toasted rye in the middle |
$17.99 |
Scott's Clubbrisket and pastrami melted under muenster cheese and cheddar all on rye with a potato pancake right in the middle |
$17.99 |
Kaveh's Hot Potatohot corned beef piled high covered in melted Swiss served open-faced on a potato pancake, and for good measure there is another one the same way with pastrami |
$18.49 |
Soup
Bowl of Soup |
$4.29 |
Mish Mosh Soupmatzoh ball, kreplach and chicken noodle in a big bowl |
$7.99 |
Classic Deli Side Dishes
Potato Pancake |
$1.79 |
Potato Knish |
$1.79 |
Kishka |
$1.79 |
Desserts
Rugelach |
$1.69/ each |
Mandel Bread |
$5.99/ lb. |
Black and White Cookie |
$2.25 |
Beverages
Coffee |
$1.79 |
Chocolate Phosphate |
$1.95 |
NY Egg Cream |
$1.95 |
Dr. Brown's Soda |
$1.59 |
Iced Tea |
$1.69 |
Fountain Drink |
$1.69 |
Breakfast Platters
all platter served with cream cheese, tomato, onion, cucumber, olives and your choice of bagel
Keith's Lox Platter |
$8.59 |
Marshall's 3 Scoop Plattersalmon salad, whitefish salad and tuna salad |
$9.79 |
Signature Sandwiches
(Two Sizes: Junior OR New York Style)
Bensonhurstcorned beef and pastrami under melted swiss on rye |
$7.99/11.49 |
Lou's Second Cityturkey and salami with muenster cheese on a pretzel roll |
$8.49/11.49 |
Safron CPRour veggie sandwich!...cheddar and provolone with lettuce, tomato, onion and cucumber on wheat |
$7.49 |
Smokey Joelox and whitefish salad with tomato on challah bread with chive cream cheese |
$8.99 |
Reubencorned beef and sauerkraut under melted swiss with thousand island dressing on toasted rye |
$7.99/11.99 |
Rachelthe turkey reuben...turkey and coleslaw under melted swiss with thousand island on a toasted pretzel roll |
$8.99/12.49 |
Tuna Meltcheddar cheese melted over a tomato and our tuna salad on both halves of a toasted bagel, served open face |
$8.49 |
The BNYa Monster sandwich...corned beef, pastrami, and brisket on an onion roll |
$12.99 |
New Yorkercorned beef with coleslaw (on the sandwich) on rye |
$7.99/10.99 |
The Manhattanturkey with coleslaw (on the sandwich), chopped liver and thousand island on rye |
$9.99/13.49 |
The Good LifeHOT roast beef with roasted red peppers under melted provolone on an onion roll |
$8.99/12.49 |
Doubledownpastrami and turkey pastrami with lettuce and tomato on rye |
$7.49/10.99 |
Southsiderturkey and roast beef with lettuce and tomato on an onion roll |
$7.49/10.99 |
SoVocorned beef and chopped liver on rye |
$9.99/13.49 |
Smoke DaddyHOT Homemade Brisket in BBQ Sauce with Onion Rings and Cheddar on an Onion Roll |
$8.99/12.49 |
Hot Egg Sandwiches
all served on toasted challah bread
Egg & Cheddar Cheese |
$4.59 |
Salami, Egg & Muenster Cheese |
$5.79 |
Corned Beef, Egg & Swiss Cheese |
$5.79 |
Lox, Egg & Cream Cheese |
$5.99 |
BIG EGG SANDWICHsalami, egg, muenster and cheddar and a potato pancake on a pretzel roll |
$7.55 |
Big Salads
dressings on the side, half salad and cup of soup...same price as big salad
Caesarromaine lettuce with tomato, asiago cheese, hard-boiled egg, croutons and creamy caesar dressing |
$7.25 |
Chicken Caesar Saladsame as above but with chicken |
$8.49 |
Big Applechicken, diced apples, dried cherries, and blue cheese over mized greens with balsamic vinaigrette |
$8.49 |
Greek Saladromaine lettuce, tomatoes, feta cheese, kalamata olives, perperoncini and Greek dressing |
$7.75 |
Fruit & Nut Saladmixed greens, apple, strawberry, candied walnuts, bleu cheese and our fat-free raspberry vinaigrette dressing |
$7.75 |
Garden Saladmixed greens with lettuce, tomato, onion, cucumber, croutons and our fat-free italian dressing |
$6.99 |
Chopped Saladturkey, salami, tomato, cucumber, kalamata olives and feta cheese over mixed greens with ranch dressing |
$8.49 |
Great Lakes Saladmixed greens and diced chicken with tomato, cucumber, bleu cheese, a hard-boiled egg and thousand island dressing |
$8.49 |
BBQ Chicken Saladromaine lettuce, tomato, cucumber and onion with BBQ chicken, topped with tortilla strips and shredded cheddar cheese |
$8.49 |



